There are so many solutions and products available for home surveillance. #CCTV #monitoring
The Solution should be simplest to use but must have the best features. But technology moves so fast that it is though for a common man to find a best suitable product or solution. (Please note that I am referring to the home security system here, and not the offices or factories. I shall cover office security systems in the next article.)
After analyzing and using various products, I found that all the available solutions in the market are deficient in at least one feature. You cannot get all the things in one; so priorities the solutions as per your requirements.
Detection: Motion detection, Human detection, Face detection, Zones line crossing
Recording Options: Dvr, NVR, NAS, SD card, cloud, email snapshots
Connectivity: Wireless or wired
Display or viewing options: TV screen, android TV, firestick, NVR/DVR, mobile, tablet
Notifications or alerts: Detection means nothing if we do not get notifications.
we cannot lay wires all around the home. Wireless is more feasible
we want flexibility to move camera as per need such as to monitor maids or Babies.
we cannot dedicate a space for display screen, DVR, NVR & clumsy IT equipment.
we want a simple solution that can be operated by all family members who may not be technology Savvy.
we want an economical solution.
we do not want CCTV vendor should visit our home more often. Neither we can put any dedicated person for maintenance or assistance.
we want to feel that our home is under our control, even if we are busy or away from our home.
There is no point of unnecessary recordings of useless motions or still building; any number of storage will be less. When we need to find anything in the recording it will be very tedious job to traverse to find the desired frame.
Notification would be useless if we get notifications alerts even by moving leaves, mosquitoes, vehicle at roadside. Eventually we will get irritated and turn off all the new notifications.
So the notifications or alerts should be event-based and solution should also be able to differentiate between human or other objects. Called as Human detection. Next is face detection, but it is still costly & offered by a very few brands.
Notification should be scheduled-based as well as mode-based.
For home, the solution should trigger notifications when we are in away mode. for example; If we are going for shopping in daytime after locking the house; it should trigger us if someone enters our home. Even guard enters in an area where he is not suppose to enter, we must get a notification. (zone feature)
We can mark zone. We can mark areas near gate as one zone so that camera can neglect any movement on road but triggers alerts and do recordings if someone from road enters marked zone (the area near the gate).
I checked solutions of following brands, which I believe are the best in the market:
Hikvision, MI, EZVIZ, IMOU, CP plus, Godrej, Matrix, hero (Qubo) and Many more
If NVR/DVR vendor is saying that they support all other brands camera using (ONVIF protocol), do not fall into it. It may loose intelligent or event based recordings.
Moreover we may be needing different app and software to view live or recordings. So integration would be an additional challenge.
So best if you keep single brand of all the devices for home monitoring.
Cameras can be wired or wireless or both
Wires can be coaxial for analogue cameras or cat5 computer LAN wire for IP-based cam
If laying of wires are not feasible we can go with wireless cameras. wireless and wired devices can mix match. If you are buying wireless camera, please make sure you have wifi signals around.
For example we can connect a few wired cameras & a few wireless camera to the hybrid NVR/NAS/Cloud.
To make your whole home as wireless zone, there are many solutions. The latest is Wifi Mesh. I would recommend Deco M5. I would also write a full blog on this later.
There is no point of recording continuously and endlessly of empty room or road or place having irrelevant motion. We should record only important things which has human motion or useful captures to save storage & other cost.
Now there is a risk of data storage device get stolen or snatched by authorities and destroy the evidence.
We can store it at any location which is hidden at a safe place or better at an offsite location that is cloud
DVR/NVR: It has two purposes:
To record all the cameras feeding to hard disk
To display cameras feeds on a TV or a screen
NAS: dedicated hard disk having a network port
SD card: Locally installed memory card, this can store a few days recording and is used as a buffer between NVR DVR or a cloud
Cloud: In today’s era, its the latest and most appropriate option. We can put our recordings at servers of service providers. We can retrieve recordings, if local storage or device get stolen or if you want to play while travelling. Subscription fee is applicable for cloud recording depending on the number of days of recording you want to retain.
Email snapshots: motions can be captured as a picture and can be sent to your email inbox or can be pushed to your mobile app.
Power can be supplied to cam in many ways
Connecting Cam adapters with direct electric board
Through PoE network switch.
POE injector.
SMPS, for sending power along with network wire.
For home monitoring, I found Qubo security solution by Hero Group as the best and it satisfies most of the requirements unless you have the mindset not to pay for any subscription, you can go with this. I will recommend to go with subscription. Plan starts from Free (1 day recording/500MB) , Rs. 600 per year for 7 days recording/5GB , Rs.1200 per year for one month recording/20GB. Single plan can be shared among all the camera, but obviously number of days would be reduced due to storage limit.
Why you should buy Qubo:
Indian brand by trusted HERO group. This cam has a very good two way audio quality, can record to SD Card and cloud. It can detect human motion, it has wireless connectivity, it is economical to buy. economical cloud subscription. weather restraint. Moreover, you can watch through Amazon Fire stick.
Why you should not buy Qubo:
It doesn't support viewing multiple camera in single screen.It doesn't support recording to NAS. You do not want to pay for any subscription.
My second choice is MI cam by Xiaomi if you do not want to pay for cloud subscription.
MI Cam can record on SD card & NAS simultaneously, so it will give you a good solution but it is not weather restraint so you need to take necessary precaution to protect it from water and sunlight. Best for indoor use only.
Why you should not buy MI:
Chinese company. Cloud recording is not supported. May not survive in rain & sunlight.
IMOU By Dahua was my choice, due to many features in single solution, but I couldn't find the required NVR in India. Standalone IMOU camera doesn't support recording to NAS. IMOU Cloud is 5 times costlier than Qubo cloud.
EZVIZ by Hikvision is not offering cloud to people located in India; its costing 10 times costlier than Qubo cloud as per price in UK. & it is not supporting human detection in most of the models. So I did not chose this. Else IMOU & EZVIZ are good products, though both companies are Chinese.
If you have not opted for subscription service or your cam doesn't support cloud recording, you may buy NAS, that will act as recording device without a need of NVR or a DVR. NAS recording is supported by MI CAM. Even you can keep recording of many months. You should add SD Card as well, along with NAS. As SD card acts as a buffer & make sure it records even if the network connectivity is broken. During my test, Hikvision failed to record on NAS, even when they claimed that NAS is supported. Mi CAM recorded on NAS without a fail.
For home you may not like to put a big screen attached to NVR/DVR and make messy or clumsy control room. Even if you do, you cannot watch it from every room. Even watching cam all the time on your TV screen is also not feasible. I would advise you to buy a tablet, install viewing app and put it in bedroom or anywhere you go. Even you can take it take it to your holidays or friend's home & watch live (better to buy with 4G sim option). You can also use it as a mobile door phone. If you get a visitor at door, app installed will get a notification, it will act as a bell & your camera will act as a door phone.
Yes! you can do the same with your android or Apple phone also, but to view dedicatedly you need some dedicated screen.
Note: Regular HIKVISION, DAHUA, CPPLUS DVR/NVR are suitable for office & factories not for home.
Hikvision vendor in Moradabad: 9897037939
CP Plus vendor in Moradabad: 9639933853
Generic brand economical DVR/NVR: 9410678311
Do not ever hang a pad lock on front gate. This is an invitation to a thief.
After entering any house, a thief will do the following:
Shutdown electricity from main power distribution box or invertor so that all the monitoring equipment & lights will turn off.
Search for camera recording device such as DVR/NVR & will take away to safe guard himself.
Search for steel almirah or lockers and break it first.
Break all the locked doors in the house.
We all know that we should install camera & recording system, but nowadays, thieves are smarter.
Do not hang padlock at the door.
Put camera recording to cloud.
(Thief will take away your camera or DVR or both)
Set motion detection & human detection based notification; should be sent to your mobile.
Camera should send you a notification as soon as it goes offline.
Camera should send an email with the photo attached in case of any event.
You can attach small battery bank with the camera. This can be hidden besides camera gangbox.
You need to select a gangbox size depending on the adapter, two pin plug & battery bank size. You can leave this to your local electrician.
Attach a router UPS with your Internet modem & wifi distribution devices. Check volts & Ampere required by each device before buying. Most popular volts are 12V, 9V, 5V. 2A must be sufficient.
This yellow battery is a very cheap alternatives of 12V battery banks and can be used in routers, switches and camera operating at 12V DC. It has charger protection.